More Than A Feeling Part 1 — Don’t Forget Who Did It — In this episode of After The Amen, Keith Webb and Kastle Jones revisit Pastor Joshua Gay’s message from Luke 17:11–19 and talk about the difference between being thankful for the blessing and remembering the One who gave it. They discuss why it’s so easy to move on after an answered prayer, how gratitude should draw us closer to God, and why the blessing should never take the Blesser’s place. This conversation challenges us to be the one who returns, remembers what God has done, and lets thanksgiving become worship.

Strange Tales Part 5 — Don’t Let Fear Pick Your Voice — In this episode of After The Amen, Garrett Morlan and Keith Webb revisit Pastor Joshua Gay’s message from 1 Samuel 28:3–25 and the unsettling story of Saul seeking guidance from a medium. They talk about how fear can push us toward the wrong voices, why not everything spiritual is from God, and the importance of staying anchored to God’s Word when pressure rises. This conversation reminds us that we do not have to let fear choose our direction—we can bring our questions, uncertainty, and fear to Jesus and trust Him as the voice we follow.

Strange Tales Part 4 — In this episode of After The Amen, Garrett Morlan and Keith Webb revisit Pastor Joshua Gay’s message from Daniel 5:1–12 and the mysterious handwriting on the wall. They discuss how Daniel’s commitment to living a consecrated life positioned him for elevation and favor, even in a culture that did not honor God. In a world that constantly pressures us to compromise, it can be tempting to blend in, take shortcuts, or chase opportunities on our own. But Daniel’s story reminds us that faithfulness in private prepares us for opportunities in public. When we choose to honor God with our decisions, character, and daily lives, we position ourselves for His purpose. Consecration leads to elevation, and faithfulness makes room for God's favor.

Strange Tales Part 3 — God Has Not Lost — In this episode of After The Amen, Garrett Morlan and Keith Webb revisit Pastor Joshua Gay’s message from 1 Samuel 5:1–6 and talk through what it means to trust God when a setback makes it feel like the enemy has won. They discuss how fear, shame, and disappointment can try to speak the final word, why a painful chapter does not define the whole story, and the difference between what looks like defeat and what is actually true about God’s authority. This conversation reminds us that God has not lost, His Word still stands, and His hand is still strong enough to hold us.

Strange Tales Part 2 — In this episode of After The Amen, Keith Webb and Kastle Jones revisit Pastor Robert Gay’s message from 2 Kings 6:1–7 and the strange story of the floating axe head. They talk about what this miracle teaches us about God’s provision, His ability to step into situations that feel impossible, and what it looks like to trust Him with the things we’ve lost, broken, or can’t fix on our own. Together, they unpack how Pastor Robert’s message applies to everyday life and challenge us to keep moving in faith, cast our “stick” upon the water, and believe that God can turn our situation around for our good.

Strange Tales Part 1 — In this episode of After The Amen, Garrett Morlan and Keith Webb revisit Pastor Joshua Gay’s message from 2 Kings 6:8–23 and talk through what it means to trust God when what we see feels overwhelming. They discuss the difference between seeing a situation correctly and seeing it completely, why fear tends to focus on everything that is against us, and how faith brings God back into the equation. This conversation challenges us to stop letting our circumstances have the final word and to pray, “Lord, open my eyes,” so we can recognize that God is present, working, and greater than anything surrounding us.

In this episode of After The Amen, Pastor Garrett Morlan is joined by Keith Webb to revisit Beyond Part 3 from Pastor Joshua Gay. Together, they unpack key moments from Zechariah 4:1–10, talk about what stood out from the message, and discuss how we can rely on the Spirit of God instead of our own strength as we walk out what He has called us to do. It’s a practical conversation about taking Sunday’s message beyond the service and applying it to everyday life.