SHOW / EPISODE

Is It Cake? Halloween | Still Watchin’

54m | Oct 11, 2026

Is it cake—or is it just a lot of edible clay? Josh Sroka and Robb Spewak take on Is It Cake? Halloween and discover that liking cake, game shows, and Mikey Day does not necessarily mean liking all three together.


From suspiciously easy reveals and confusing rules to eight-hour baking sessions, celebrity judges, and Robb’s many questions about Blippi, the guys cut through the frosting to ask what this show is really serving. Josh pitches his own sheet-cake masterpiece, Robb wonders whether any of these creations would actually taste good, and the conversation takes a predictably ridiculous turn toward “sexy Blippi.”


Spoilers ahead: this discussion covers all three episodes, including the winner.


Plus, the guys tee up Love Is Blind as their next Still Watchin’ adventure.


Watch, listen, and find more from Josh and Robb at https://StillTalkinPodcast.com/



Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Paused
Audio Player Image
Still Talkin'
Loading...