A Bloody Valentine

Season 1 | Episode 89
26m | Feb 12, 2024

A doctor in Oklahoma arrives home from work on Valentine's Day to find his wife murdered. Police immediately begin looking for a suspect, but a strange message in a Valentine's card provides a dark clue. And detectives start to think the good doctor may be hiding something. Join Olivia Cornu and John Conner as they dive deep into the dark to discuss the murder of Susan Hamilton. Will this case be enough to make you check the locks?

Follow Us:



Join Our Facebook Group

Subscribe to our Patreon

Visit our website and leave a voicemail!

Subscribe and Review on Apple Podcasts

Check the Locks is Supported By: 

Audible: Enjoy 30 Days for Fee

This episode of Check the Locks is dedicated, with love, to the memory of our friend Mathew Scott Halliday. 


Abortion doctor strangled and beat his wife to death on Valentine's Day before returning to work - Mirror Online

Susan Hamilton Murder: Where Is Dr. John Hamilton Now?

A Valentine's Day Murder in Oklahoma - ABC News

Valentine’s Day Murder. A case of the husband who loved his… | by Karen Marie Shelton | CrimeBeat | Medium

Doctor told to be thankful for life sentence

Inmate Search: John Baxter Hamilton 413355, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Support this podcast at —

Advertising Inquiries:

Privacy & Opt-Out:
Audio Player Image
Check The Locks: A True Crime Podcast