One Hour with New York at Gunpoint: The Taking of Pelham 123 (1974 & 2009)
17m | Sep 22, 2026The question appears simple: which version of The Taking of Pelham 123 is better? Alex Al-Kazzaz, aka The Bear of Texas, rejects the easy verdict and examines how the same one-hour ransom crisis produced two radically different thrillers. Walter Matthau and Robert Shaw command a grimy, methodical battle of wits in 1974, while Denzel Washington and John Travolta drive a faster, more volatile psychological confrontation in 2009. From the opposing interpretations of Garber and the hijackers to the changing portrayal of New York City itself, the remake never travels exactly as the original did—and both films are stronger for it.
🔥🎬
Follow Alex on X!
@BearManofTX and @BearTX_podcast
Follow Alex on Instagram!
thebearoftx and thebearoftexaspodcast
Follow Alex on TikTok!
thebearoftexas
