SHOW / EPISODE

EP14 | The Death of Materialism: Why Panpsychism is the New Worldview

2h 9m | Mar 13, 2026

Is the universe a mindless machine, or is it alive? In this episode, we explore the dramatic collapse of materialism and the rise of Panpsychism—the radical idea that consciousness is a fundamental feature of all matter.


From the "Hard Problem of Consciousness" to the return of ancient animism in the modern lab, we sit down with Anthony Costello and Carl Teichrib to deconstruct how modern philosophy is "re-enchanting" the world. Are we unified souls created by a transcendent God, or are we merely temporary "eddies" in a cosmic river of mind?


📘 Check out my book here: https://shorturl.at/u3MGp


In this episode, we discuss:

Galileo’s Error: How science accidentally "shaved off" the soul.

The New Paganism: Why elite academics are suddenly sounding like ancient animists.

The "Combination Problem": The logical flaw that panpsychists can't explain.

Psychedelics & Magic: Are altered states revealing reality or just altering perception?

The Theology of Gender: Why the shift toward "Internal Experience" is feminizing the church.

The Moral Motivation: Why some philosophers prefer a "Conscious Universe" over a Personal God.


Timestamps

0:00 - Intro: The Death of Materialism

12:45 - Thomas Nagel & The Hard Problem of Consciousness

28:30 - What is Panpsychism? (Bottom-Up vs. Top-Down)

45:15 - The "Epstein Connection" and Controlling Consciousness

58:00 - Is the Universe Divine? Panentheism vs. Pantheism

01:15:30 - Modern Animism: Why your computer might have "feelings"

01:30:45 - The "Feminization" of Spirituality & The Deification of Nature

01:45:20 - Why Panpsychism is "Ad Hoc" (The Theistic Critique)

02:00:10 - Final Verdict: Soul vs. Cosmic Eddy


Key Resources Mentioned

Galileo's Error by Philip Goff

Mind and Cosmos by Thomas Nagel

Knowledge and the Case for Dualism by Richard Fumerton

The Argument from Consciousness by J.P. Moreland


Take the Next Step in Your Education

If this conversation has sparked a desire to go deeper into the intersection of theology, science, and the soul, I want to invite you to explore our advanced programs. Equip yourself to engage the modern world with intellectual rigour and spiritual depth. Explore Our Degree Programs Here: https://degrees.soulscienceministries.com/


#Panpsychism #PhilosophyOfMind #Theology #Apologetics #Consciousness #HardProblem #NewPaganism #ChristianPhilosophy #Metaphysics

Paused
Audio Player Image
It's a Theological World After All
Loading...