SHOW / EPISODE

6 - The Servant Girl Annihilator

56m | Nov 2, 2026

Austin, Texas. 1885. A city gripped by fear, a string of brutal murders, and a killer who may have walked away undiscovered.

Known as the Servant Girl Annihilator, this series of attacks left Austin searching for answers and historians debating one chilling question: Was it one killer or several?

We dig into the victims, the investigation, the suspects, and the mysterious Nathan Elgin—a man whose connection to a peculiar piece of evidence might make him the most compelling suspect of all.

Was Nathan the killer? Or has the truth been hiding in the shadows for over 140 years?

Have a theory? Think we missed something? We want to hear from you!

Email: open@cookedandcuriouspod.com

Stay curious. Question everything. And remember… I could be wrong.

Paused
Audio Player Image
Cooked & Curious
Loading...