SHOW / EPISODE

The Case Against Prescriptivism in Editing Fiction

31m | Nov 1, 2026

When it comes to editing fiction, it asks a lot of us.

We need to understand structure, character, pacing, point of view, voice, and sentence-level craft—but knowing the techniques is only part of the job. The harder skill is knowing when to use them, when to question them, and when to leave an author’s choices alone.

In this episode of The Editor’s Half Hour, I talk with Sophie Playle of Liminal Pages about the craft of editing fiction, especially speculative and literary fiction.

We explore the difference between using editorial frameworks as helpful tools and treating them like formulas, along with worldbuilding, character development, line editing, voice, and the judgment required to support an author without taking over the work.

Sophie also shares insights from her experience as an editor and educator and offers a thoughtful perspective on what it takes to edit fiction with both skill and restraint.

After more than a decade running a successful freelance editing business specializing in fiction, Sophie trains editors to approach novel editing with confidence and rigor. Her courses are recognized by the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and are shaped by hands-on experience, advanced study in Creative Writing, and years of professional development.

Visit liminalpages.com to learn more about Sophie and her courses.

______________________

Leave a review or share this episode with your fellow editors!

Check out other episodes of The Editor’s Half Hour: piquepublishing.com/podcast

Connect with me on Instagram: @Editors_Half_Hour

Subscribe to my newsletter: tinyurl.com/EditorsHalfHour

Become a Patreon Sneak “Pique” supporter for $5/month to get access to exclusive content on YouTube: patreon.com/EditorsHalfHour

Visit piquepublishing.com/shop to subscribe to Pique Post: The Mail Club for Editing Pros(e). 

Paused
Audio Player Image
The Editor's Half Hour
Loading...